Semi-Inground vs. Above Ground Pools: Which One is Right for You?
Nothing transforms a backyard quite like a pool. Whether you're dreaming of a refreshing dip on a hot day or a fun space for the whole family to enjoy, choosing the right pool can feel like a big decision.
Semi-inground and above-ground pools both offer fantastic benefits, but they’re built differently, have unique costs, and suit different lifestyles. Let’s break it all down so you can decide which one is the best fit for your home.
What Are Semi-Inground and Above Ground Pools?
Pros and Cons of Semi-Inground Pools
Pros and Cons of Above Ground Pools
Cost Comparison
Installation Process: What to Expect
Maintenance and Upkeep: Keeping Your Pool in Top Shape
Aesthetic and Design Considerations
Which Pool Type Is Best for You?
What Are Semi-Inground and Above Ground Pools?
Both semi-inground and above-ground pools give you a backyard oasis, but their designs and installations set them apart.
A semi-inground pool is installed partially in the ground, typically with a portion of the pool wall exposed. This design blends seamlessly with landscaping, decks, and patios, creating a sleek, almost built-in look.
It’s a great choice for homeowners who want something more permanent and customizable without committing to a fully in-ground structure.
An above-ground pool sits entirely on top of the ground, supported by a sturdy frame and liner system.
These pools come in a range of sizes and shapes, and they’re perfect for those who want a quick, budget-friendly way to enjoy swimming without major construction.
Many above-ground pools can be taken down and relocated (for a fee), making them a slightly more flexible option.
Pros and Cons of Semi-Inground Pools
Why Homeowners Love Them Semi-inground pools offer the best of both worlds. They provide a more integrated and stylish look than above-ground pools while avoiding the high costs of a fully in-ground installation.
They also tend to be sturdier, often made from reinforced materials designed to withstand years of use. Being partially buried also helps with insulation, which can keep the water temperature more stable.
If you’re looking for a pool that complements your backyard’s landscaping and adds to your home’s value, a semi-inground pool checks those boxes.
Things to Consider Since a semi-inground pool requires some excavation and professional installation, it does come with a higher upfront cost.
It’s also more permanent than an above-ground option, meaning relocation isn't typically an option. Installation takes longer & often involves additional landscaping work, like building retaining walls or integrating decking.
Pros and Cons of Above Ground Pools
Why They’re a Popular Choice Above-ground pools are one of the easiest ways to bring a pool into your backyard. They’re affordable, fast to install, and don’t require major landscaping changes.
Many models can be set up in a weekend, making them perfect for families eager to start swimming right away.
Another big advantage is flexibility. If you ever decide to move or upgrade, you can take down an above-ground pool and start fresh.
These pools also have lower maintenance costs over time, since they typically use smaller filtration systems and require less upkeep.
Things to Consider While above-ground pools are convenient, they don’t have the same polished look as a semi-inground pool.
The lifespan of an above-ground pool is also generally shorter, with materials that can wear down over time due to weather and use.
They’re also not as customizable when it comes to depth or shape, and they don’t add much in terms of property value.
Cost Comparison
The cost of a pool depends on its size, materials, and installation process.
Above-ground pools typically range from $2,000 to $8,000, depending on quality and features. Many people opt for DIY installation, which saves on labor costs.
Semi-inground pools tend to cost between $10,000 and $25,000, factoring in excavation, professional installation, and potential landscaping.
Installation Process: What to Expect
Setting Up an Above-Ground Pool Installation for an above-ground pool is straightforward. After selecting a level spot in your yard, a base is prepared using sand or a protective liner.
The frame is assembled, the liner is secured, and the pool is filled. Depending on the model, this process can take anywhere from a few hours to a couple of days.
Installing a Semi-Inground Pool A semi-inground pool requires excavation, which means more planning. The depth and positioning are determined first, then the area is dug out.
Once the pool walls are placed, the space around it is backfilled for support.
Additional features like decking or landscaping may extend the installation time, but the end result is a durable, polished pool that feels like part of your backyard.
Maintenance and Upkeep: Keeping Your Pool in Top Shape
Both types of pools require routine care to stay clean and functional.
Cleaning & Water Treatment: Regular skimming, vacuuming, and balancing chemicals are necessary for both semi-inground and above-ground pools.
Seasonal Maintenance: Winterizing is important, especially in colder climates, to prevent damage from freezing temperatures.
Above-ground pools may need their liners replaced over time, while semi-inground pools may require occasional repairs to their walls or filtration systems.
Lifespan Expectations: Above-ground pools typically last 7 to 15 years, depending on the materials and upkeep. Semi-inground pools have a longer lifespan, often lasting 20 years or more with proper maintenance.
Aesthetic and Design Considerations
A pool is more than just a place to swim—it’s part of your outdoor space.
Semi-inground pools integrate beautifully with decks, patios, and landscaping. Homeowners can add stone, wood, or tile surrounds for a sleek look.
Above-ground pools can still be enhanced with features like wraparound decks, decorative panels, and lighting. While they don’t have the same built-in aesthetic, a well-designed above-ground pool can be just as inviting.
Which Pool Type Is Best for You?
The right choice comes down to your lifestyle, budget, and backyard space.
If you want a permanent, stylish pool that adds value and blends with your landscaping, a semi-inground pool is a great investment.
If you’re looking for a budget-friendly, easy-to-install option that offers fun without the commitment, an above-ground pool is the way to go.
For homeowners who plan to move or want flexibility, above-ground pools offer the advantage of portability.
If your yard has an uneven landscape or slopes, a semi-inground pool can be installed to fit the terrain beautifully.
Both semi-inground and above-ground pools bring fun, relaxation, and value to your backyard. The best choice depends on what works for your space, budget, and long-term plans.
No matter which option you go with, having a pool means more time outdoors, more summer memories, and a refreshing escape just steps from your home!
**FAQs**
What’s the main difference between semi-inground and above-ground pools?
Which type of pool lasts longer?
Do semi-inground pools require professional installation?
How much maintenance does each pool require?
Which pool is better for small yards?
How do installation costs compare?
Can I build a deck around both types of pools?
What’s the main difference between semi-inground and above-ground pools?
- The primary difference is how the pools are installed. Semi-inground pools are partially buried into the ground, giving them a built-in, permanent appearance. Above-ground pools, on the other hand, are fully above the ground and supported by a frame and liner system.
Semi-inground pools offer a more integrated look with landscaping, while above-ground pools are often quicker and more affordable to install.
Which type of pool lasts longer?
- Semi-inground pools typically have a longer lifespan, lasting 20 years or more with proper care. The materials used in their construction (often steel or resin) are built for durability. Above-ground pools, while still long-lasting, generally last between 7 to 15 years due to the more exposed structure and materials that can wear down over time.
Do semi-inground pools require professional installation?
- Yes, semi-inground pools generally require professional installation due to the excavation process, site preparation, and structural complexity. Professionals will ensure the pool is properly installed, level, and supported, which helps ensure its longevity and safety.
How much maintenance does each pool require?
- Both pool types need regular cleaning, water treatment, and seasonal maintenance. Above-ground pools tend to have simpler filtration systems and less involved structural upkeep.
Semi-inground pools may require more attention to landscaping, structural components, and the pool’s built-in systems, but the overall maintenance isn’t much more than an above-ground pool if you stay on top of it.
Which pool is better for small yards?
- If you have a small yard, above-ground pools are often the better choice due to their flexible sizing and quicker installation. They don’t require as much space for excavation or additional landscaping. That said, a semi-inground pool can still fit in smaller yards, especially if the terrain is uneven, but it will need more planning and professional installation.
How do installation costs compare?
- Above-ground pools are more affordable to install. Installation is often quick and can sometimes be a DIY project. Semi-inground pools are more expensive due to the excavation and professional installation required.
Can I build a deck around both types of pools?
- Yes, you can build a deck around both semi-inground and above-ground pools. For above-ground pools, a deck can elevate the pool and create a more polished look. For semi-inground pools, decking can enhance the built-in appearance, making the pool blend seamlessly into your landscape. Both options give you the flexibility to customize your backyard retreat.
To see some examples of semi-inground pools with decks built around them, check out our Radiant Gallery!